OWNING YOUR IMAGE: THE RISE OF “RIGHT TO PUBLICITY” IN INDIA – ZFILING FINANCIAL SERVICE
BY: SMRITI BERLIA , BBA LLB 4TH YEAR , ZFILING FINANCIAL SERVICE
1. INTRODUCTION
In recent years, the concept of the “right to publicity” has garnered significant attention in India, particularly in the context of celebrities and public figures. As India’s entertainment and sports industries continue to grow, the commercial exploitation of a person’s image, name, or likeness has become a valuable asset. The “right to publicity” is essentially the right of an individual to control and profit from the commercial use of their identity. However, the legal framework around this right is still evolving in India. This article delves into the legal arguments for and against the right to publicity in India and explores its potential impact on industries like entertainment, sports, and advertising.
2. WHAT IS THE RIGHT TO PUBLICITY?
The “right to publicity” is an offshoot of the broader right to privacy. It provides an individual, especially a celebrity or public figure, the right to control how their image, name, voice, signature, or other aspects of their persona are used commercially. The right to publicity ensures that no one can profit from a person’s identity without their consent, protecting them from unauthorized commercial exploitation.
Globally, jurisdictions like the United States have long recognized the right to publicity. However, in India, this right is still in a nascent stage, primarily because there is no codified law specifically dealing with this issue. Nevertheless, Indian courts have been proactive in interpreting existing legal principles to address claims related to the unauthorized use of a celebrity’s persona.
3. LEGAL BASIS OF THE RIGHT TO PUBLICITY IN INDIA
India’s legal system lacks a specific statute that directly governs the right to publicity. However, courts have often relied on various provisions from intellectual property laws, the Indian Constitution, and judicial interpretations to establish and protect this right.
- Judicial Precedents: One of the most landmark judgments in this regard is ICC Development (International) Ltd. v. Arvee Enterprises & Anr. (2003), where the Delhi High Court held that the unauthorized use of a celebrity’s persona for commercial gain was The court emphasized that the right to publicity stems from the individual’s right to control the commercial use of their identity and prevent unauthorized exploitation.
- Another critical judgment is the M. Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. v. Baby Gift House and Ors. (2010) case. Here, the Delhi High Court ruled in favor of the famous Indian singer Daler Mehndi, affirming that the use of his likeness on products without his consent violated his right to publicity.
These cases have established a foundation for recognizing the right to publicity, though they often rely on existing tort law principles, such as passing off and misappropriation, rather than a specific legal provision.
- Right to Privacy and Article 21: The right to privacy, as recognized by the Indian Supreme Court in the Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017) case, has significant implications for the right to publicity. The Supreme Court held that privacy is a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution, and part of this right is the ability of an individual to control the dissemination of personal information.
While privacy deals with the right to be left alone, the right to publicity concerns the individual’s control over their public image, especially in a commercial context. Hence, celebrities can invoke Article 21 to assert their right to publicity in situations where their persona is exploited without consent.
- Intellectual Property Laws: Trademark law in India also provides some protection for an individual’s Under the Trade Marks Act, 1999, celebrities can register their name, likeness, or other attributes of their persona as trademarks, thus preventing unauthorized commercial use.
4. ARGUMENTS FOR THE RIGHT TO PUBLICITY
- Protection Against Commercial Exploitation: One of the strongest arguments for the recognition of the right to publicity is that it prevents unauthorized commercial exploitation of an individual’s identity. Celebrities invest considerable effort in building their public image, and they should have exclusive control over its commercial use. The absence of a clear legal framework allows third parties to exploit their likeness for profit without compensating them.
- Right to Control One’s Image: In an increasingly digital world, individuals, particularly celebrities, need to maintain control over their public persona. Unauthorized use of their image can lead to reputational harm or association with brands and products they may not wish to endorse. The right to publicity ensures that the celebrity retains control over where and how their image is
- Economic Value: Celebrities’ personas carry significant economic value. In India, brands spend millions to associate their products with well-known public figures, which is why ensuring that celebrities are compensated fairly for the commercial use of their image is essential. The right to publicity gives individuals the power to monetize their persona, much like an intellectual property right.
5. ARGUMENTS AGAINST THE RIGHT TO PUBLICITY
- Freedom of Speech and Expression: One of the major concerns with granting a strong right to publicity is that it may conflict with the right to freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) of the Indian Constitution. The media often uses the image of public figures in reporting and commentary, and excessive protection of the right to publicity could hinder free speech, especially in the context of news reporting, satire, or artistic expression.
- Over-Commercialization: Critics argue that recognizing an expansive right to publicity could lead to an over-commercialization of identity. Every reference to a celebrity, no matter how incidental or inconsequential, could result in legal claims. This could stifle creativity in fields like cinema, literature, and even journalism, where celebrities are often mentioned without the intent of commercial exploitation.
- Lack of Public Interest Safeguard: If the right to publicity is recognized without appropriate safeguards, it could be misused to prevent legitimate public interest reporting or The law must strike a balance between protecting celebrities from unfair exploitation and ensuring that the public’s right to information and expression is not curtailed.
6. POTENTIAL IMPACT ON INDUSTRY
The formal recognition and codification of the right to publicity in India would have far-reaching implications for various industries:
- Entertainment and Advertising: If celebrities gain greater control over their image, it could lead to more structured endorsement deals, with clearer guidelines on compensation and usage Brands would need to ensure they have explicit authorization to use a celebrity’s likeness, potentially raising the cost of celebrity endorsements but also ensuring better protection for the individual.
- Media and News Reporting: The media would need to navigate the right to publicity carefully, particularly in distinguishing between commercial use and newsworthy references. However, safeguards for freedom of speech must ensure that legitimate journalistic activities are not hindered.
- Fashion and Merchandise: Unauthorized merchandise, such as clothing or accessories featuring celebrity images, would come under stricter This could open new revenue streams for celebrities through licensing agreements, while also curbing the use of counterfeit celebrity merchandise.
7. CONCLUSION
The rise of the right to publicity in India marks a significant shift in how personal identity is viewed in legal and commercial contexts. While there are compelling arguments for recognizing this right, particularly to protect celebrities from unauthorized exploitation, it is also essential to balance this with freedom of speech and public interest considerations. As India continues to evolve in this area, it is likely that clearer laws and guidelines will emerge, shaping the future of celebrity endorsement, media, and advertising industries.
For more insights on financial planning and to discover how compound interest can work for you, contact us today!
For financial consultancy or any advisory, you may visit our website at : www.zfiling.com
Follow us at:
Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/zfiling/
Facebook – https://www.facebook.com/zfiling/
Youtube – https://www.youtube.com/@zfilingfinance
Website – https://zfiling.com/
About Us – https://zfiling.com/about-zfiling/
Contact us – https://zfiling.com/contact-zfiling/
#IncomeTaxReturn #ITRFiling #TaxFiling #IncomeTax #ITR2024 #IncomeTaxIndia #TaxDeadline #FileYourITR #IncomeTaxFiling #IncomeTaxReturn2024 #TaxReturn #TaxSeason #ITRDeadline #TaxFiling2024 #LateFiling #BelatedReturn #IncomeTaxAdvice #TaxCompliance #TaxPenalties #IncomeTaxHelp #FinancialServices #TaxConsulting #TaxPlanning #GSTFiling #Bookkeeping #TDS #TaxAdvisor #AccountingServices #BusinessCompliance #MCACompliance #ROCCompliance #CompanyRegistration #GSTRegistration #IncomeTaxConsultant #FinanceExperts #TaxConsultant #CorporateCompliance #SmallBusinessTax #FinancialAdvice #TaxExperts #zfiling
#ZFiling #ZFilingServices #ZFilingITR #ZFilingFinance #ZFilingIndia #TaxWithZFiling #ChooseZFiling #YourTaxPartner #TaxFilingWithZFiling #ExpertTaxFiling #HassleFreeTaxFiling #TrustZFiling #BestTaxServices #ZFilingSupport #TaxReturnWithZFiling #EasyTaxFiling #YourFinancePartner #ZFilingConsultants #FileWithZFiling #SupportAtZFiling
#FinanceManagement #TaxSavings #TaxPreparation #TaxPlanningTips #TaxDeductions #FinancialPlanning #IncomeTaxTips #PersonalFinance #WealthManagement #TaxRefund #FinanceConsultant #TaxRegulations #BusinessTaxes #IncomeTaxIndia2024 #FilingMadeEasy #TaxHelp #FinancialConsulting #SmartTaxFiling #IncomeTaxReturnFiling #taxknowledge #zfiling #z-filing #zfilingfinancialservices #zfiling #Z-filing
#IncomeTaxNotice #TaxAdvice #IRSNotice #TaxResolution #TaxTips #TaxFiling #TaxAudit #FinancialEducation #TaxHelp #TaxErrors #TaxDocumentation #TaxProfessional #MoneyManagement #PANVerification #IncomeTaxFiling #PermanentAccountNumber #IncomeTaxIndia #EfileTaxReturns #TaxCompliance #FinancialTips #VerifyPAN #TaxHelp #TaxAdvice #IncomeTaxRecords #TaxRegulations #PANCardVerification #TaxFilingGuide #FinancialEducation #TaxResolution